How Nutra Naturals gets analyst-grade CAC to LTV answers out of Lifetimely, without a new hire.
Market expansion, same size team
No hire needed to cover analysis work.
Replenishment timing revised
Days between orders, by product and region.
Confidence to back a direction
Cohort and product analysis they act on
"With costs rising in Australia and our US expansion in full swing, we need to know which products drive retention and ultimately profit in both markets. The Profit Agent gives us that in a single conversation. No other AI tool comes close to how it breaks down and visualizes cohort data in an instant. It saves our team hours every week and helps us spot shifts in buyer behavior while we can still act."
Georgia Cawley, Growth Marketing Manager at Nutra Naturals
About Nutra Naturals
Nutra Naturals is an Australian family-owned brand making natural, easy and delicious nutrition for the whole family since 1998. Collagen Beauty and Bone Broth are the favorites in a B-Corp certified portfolio of five hero categories, sold through retail, DTC and grocery. They already sell in the US, and serious expansion is still ahead.
The Challenge
Georgia Cawley, Growth Marketing Manager and the team need analyst questions answered every month. Why did performance move against last year, what moved AOV, and was it new customers or returning ones?
Some products bring customers in cheaply and never bring them back. With costs climbing every year, the acquisition spend has to go behind the categories that hold their LTV, not the ones that look cheap at the top.
Then the US launched. A second market running at scale, and the same size team running both.
The Solution
At the end of the month, Georgia pulls the new versus returning cohort comparison in Lifetimely and has the answer instantly, in a form she can share straight to the team.
Before they adjust acquisition spend, they read retention and LTV by product and category, including whether a first purchase in one category means they'll repurchase the same product or buy a different category in the future. That resets their category priorities.
The US got the same read, down to days between orders by category. Those timings now set the Klaviyo replenishment and cross-sell flows per region, because a US customer is only halfway through a product when an Australian customer is ready to restock. No country manager or analyst was hired to cover it.
What they asked
The kind of answers they come to the Profit Agent for:
-
Why is performance up or down versus the same month last year, and is it coming from new customers or returning customers?
-
Why is average order value tracking below target this month, and which discount, products or cohort is driving the change?
-
If someone's first order is Bone Broth, how likely are they to buy Broth again, and cross-sell into another category?
Why It Works
Adding a second market at scale usually means adding the headcount to analyze it. Nutra Naturals covered both regions with the same size team, because running the analysis simply means asking the Profit Agent to do the work.
Replenishment timing is only as good as the data behind it. Theirs is set from the real days between orders, by category and by region.
Georgia has Claude and Shopify's own reporting. For the questions that matter at month close she uses Lifetimely, where cohort performance is visible at a glance across the Profit Agent dashboards and reports. Answers that used to take hours now take minutes.
"No other AI tool comes close to how it breaks down and visualizes cohort data in an instant. It saves our team hours every week and helps us spot shifts in buyer behavior while we can still act."
Georgia Cawley, Growth Marketing Manager at Nutra Naturals
Get analyst-grade answers from your own store data
Get a 14 day free trial